If you ’re one of those the great unwashed who consider the uniqueness is imminent , you might require to tamp down a lunch . Our machine just are n’t that chic , order Alva Noë , a philosopher at the University of California at Berkeley . What we call artificial news is actually well described as impostor - intelligence .
Inan essaypublished at NPR , Noë likens supercomputer to clocks , in that they can keep time , but they really do n’t live what time is . Similarly , IBM ’s Watson did n’t “ toy ” Jeopardy ! We play Jeopardy ! using Watson .
In that sense , Noë is echoing the vista of skeptics such as Oren Etzioni , head of an AI research exploit fund by Microsoft Centennial State - founding father Paul Allen . “ Watson won Jeopardy ! , but does it know it won?”he necessitate . “ Would you countenance Watson be your Doctor of the Church ? ”
Watson , in fact , has been having a difficult fourth dimension finding utilization in the private sphere , despite IBM ’s claims that it has several real - world lotion such as investment and wellness care . As Bloomberg Businessweekreports :
Klaus - Peter Adlassnig is a computer scientist at the Medical University of Vienna and the editor - in - honcho of the journal Artificial Intelligence in Medicine . The trouble with Watson , as he sees it , is that it ’s essentially a really good search engine that can answer questions posed in natural oral communication . Over time , Watson does learn from its error , but Adlassnig distrust that the sort of knowledge Watson acquire from aesculapian texts and case studies is “ very flat and very broad . ” In a clinical scope , the computer would make for a very exhaustive but cripplingly actual - minded doc — not needs the most valuable addition to a aesculapian staff . There may well come a day when computers can spit out diagnoses and treatment regime , lead doctors fiddling to do but go in data and hone their bedside fashion , but that day has not yet come .
This is why Noë prefer the term pseud - news over unreal intelligence activity — and why he believes the mechanical continues to imprison behind the biological :
It ’s striking that even the simplest physical body of life history — the amoeba , for good example — exhibit an intelligence , an autonomy , an originality , that far outstrip even the most powerful computers . A undivided cell has a lifetime story ; it turns the medium in which it find itself into an environment and it organizes that environment into a blank space of value . It seek nutrition . It create itself — and in progress to itself it introduces intend into the universe .
Now , admittedly , unicellular organisms are not very shining — but they are smarter than clocks and supercomputers . For they have the underlying rootage of that driven , dynamic , compelling betrothal that we call life story and that we call mind . Machines do n’t have information . We work information with them . But the amoeba does have information — it gathers it , it manufacture it .
I ’ll start vex about the singularity when IBM has made motorcar that exhibit the federal agency and awareness of an ameba .
BiologyWatson
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , skill , and culture news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , delivered to your present tense .
You May Also Like
